Report: The rule of law has deteriorated significantly across the EU!
The Rule of Law Report on Freedoms published on Monday by the European Civil Liberties Union reveals that while the situation varies from one member state to another, there is a broad and substantial trend towards the rule of law facing serious challenges in recent years. The 1,000-page report is published annually, with its sixth iteration published this year being the result of cooperation between 43 human rights organizations from 21 EU countries, coordinated by the European Civil Liberties Union.
One of the most striking findings from the organization’s research is the persistence of reported violations and the overall deterioration of the rule of law across the EU. While individual countries show variations, the broader observation is that all fundamental aspects of the rule of law, namely the justice system, anti-corruption measures, media freedom, checks and balances, civic space and human rights, have faced similar and deepening challenges in recent years. This clearly highlights persistent and systemic deficiencies in the rule of law across the bloc.
"Stagnants" are countries that have remained static or made minimal progress in their rule of law indicators. This group includes Greece, Ireland, Malta, the Netherlands and Spain. "Sliders" are democratic models such as Belgium, France, Germany and Sweden, which have demonstrated isolated but nevertheless worrying declines in certain areas.
"Dismantlers" are countries where the rule of law is systematically and deliberately undermined in almost all areas, with this group consisting of Italy, Bulgaria, Croatia, Romania and Slovakia. The weakest link, and a repeat offender, was found to be Hungary. Several countries showed visible efforts to improve the state of the rule of law within the country.
“Hardworking” Estonia and the Czech Republic showed signs of genuine and systematic efforts to make improvements, highlighting the successful role of civil society in creating positive change. Poland, meanwhile, is considered a “cautionary tale” as the new government has attempted to restore judicial independence and media pluralism without achieving much progress, illustrating that addressing compromised independence of institutions is an extremely challenging and fragile endeavor.
According to the report, it is absolutely essential that the European Commission links the annual rule of law report to enforcement mechanisms, such as Article 7 infringement procedures for member states that do not respect European values or EU conditionality.
The justice system still suffers from political manipulation, insufficient resources and obstacles to legal aid, all of which undermine its independence, quality and efficiency, according to the report. The overall picture also shows that in the area of the fight against corruption, there is a persistent lack of transparency, weak law enforcement and insufficient protection of whistleblowers, leading to an erosion of trust in the integrity of the government.
Media freedom remains under threat in many countries, as political influence jeopardizes the independence of regulatory bodies and concentrated ownership stifles pluralism, with journalists facing increasing harassment and legal challenges. Checks and balances are further weakened by the excessive use of fast-track legislative processes, political interference in independent authorities, and the compromised integrity of the electoral system, all of which erode democratic and legal control over government.
Furthermore, civic spaces have continued to shrink as widespread smear campaigns encourage governments to adopt restrictive laws, particularly when it comes to the right to peaceful protest and freedom of assembly and association. Finally, human rights are under increasing pressure due to stricter migration policies, inadequate protections for vulnerable groups, and increased discrimination and hate speech affecting minorities across the region.
As the report's authors note, these domestic challenges are unfolding against a changing geopolitical landscape, with the rise of far-right populism and the democratic return in the US and global conflicts shaping Europe's political trajectory.
The growing influence of the far right threatens EU unity, while Russia’s war in Ukraine and the decline of transatlantic support for European security are testing the bloc’s resilience. Migration policies are tightening, with states tightening borders and restricting asylum rights, often in violation of international law. Meanwhile, the EU’s enforcement mechanisms remain weak, allowing illiberal tendencies to fester rather than sending a clear message about the centrality of the rule of law and fundamental rights. Without decisive action, the EU risks further democratic erosion, internal fragmentation and a weakening of its global position.
“With the rise of far-right populism and the slide of democracy in the US, the rule of law crisis in Europe deepens. The growing influence of the far-right threatens the unity of the EU, while Russia’s war in Ukraine and the rapid transformation of transatlantic ties test the bloc’s resilience. To protect the EU and the rules-based world, the European Commission must strengthen law enforcement by linking it directly to Article 7, budgetary conditionality and infringement procedures.
Poll
Oil prices hit new record as tensions in the Red Sea intensify after US attacks!
Crude oil prices hit their highest levels since March 4 after U.S. military strikes on Yemen's Houthi group in the Red Sea over the weekend. During the early......
How has this week started for the major currencies?
The US dollar appears to have had a relatively quiet weekend as it continues this Monday to be bought at 91 lek and sold at 92 lek according to the local......
Coffee prices are “flying” - The causes are unfavorable climatic conditions and export restrictions
World coffee prices reached a multi-year high in 2024, rising 38.8 percent from the average a year earlier, largely driven by bad weather affecting major......
Summer Day boosts local trade - Craftsmen: This day serves to advertise our products
Summer Day fills the streets of Albania with joy, celebrations, and the scent of ballroom dancing. This traditional celebration marks the arrival of spring,......
Reduction in the price of energy, 200 million lek savings - OSHEE: 1.7 million subscribers benefited from the tariff of 8.5 lek/kWh
1.7 million subscribers have benefited from the reduction in the price of electricity, while the value saved for the February bill is 200 million lekë. The......
Russia uses cryptocurrencies for oil trading - Digital currencies serve the Kremlin to avoid sanctions
Russia is using cryptocurrencies in its oil trade with China and India to evade Western sanctions, according to four sources with direct knowledge of the......
Murriz Tunnel opens for traffic - Arbri Road/Travel costs decrease, residents expect agrotourism development
The Murriz Tunnel, the most important work on the Arbri road, has been opened to vehicle traffic, significantly shortening the travel time from Tirana to......
Amazon, Google, Meta "boost" nuclear energy - Companies support tripling capacity by 2050
Amazon, Google and Meta stated that they support efforts to achieve at least a tripling of nuclear energy worldwide by 2050. Tech companies signed a pledge......
